We All Saw It Coming. Work Comp Deteriorating

Fitch has announced that they highly doubt that the industry work comp combined ratio will come in under 110. Thats right , they are expecting higher than a 110 combines for the work comp line of business. Well, this is to be expected after the last 5 years of under priced policies that we all experienced. In my State of Delaware the rates were reduced and even rolled back to the point that they were unsustainable. All over the country this was happening and the soft market competition just added fuel to the fire. Now insurance companies are bleeding red ink on work comp. It is expected to get worse over the next two years as reserves were inadequate to cover the "chickens" that have now come home to roost. Most companies are foolishly trying to get all thier premium back in one full swoop with double digit work comp rate increases. Well this strategy won't work because one, clients can't afford it in a recession economy, two, there are companies out there still underpricing comp, and three, the health insurers are increasing rates too so there is nothing left in the money pile to pay comp. Clients will just keep shopping until they find comp rates that they can pay or downsize payroll which regardless of what we may hear on the TV, is still occurring.
A wise old insurance man told me when I was a young broker, "the insurance business is the only industry that does not know how to price their product".  I believe this to be true but not from ignorance of actuarial science but of ignorance to the by- product of competition.  Competition is good but if not held in check can push results in the "bad apple" pile. Lets hope that the industry can learn a lesson from this and price more appropriately in the next soft market. In my opinion, I doubt it!
Until next time be careful out there and know your risks. K

Popular posts from this blog

Delaware Legislature Preparing To Revisit Dram Shop Liability

Here we go again. Representative Peterson is preparing to introduce limited dram shop liability for consideration. The legislation caps the liability at $250,000 but, as is usually the case, this creates a starting point where limits are eventually increased once it's decided by the powers that be that the current limit is too low. This also puts restaurants, bars, etc, at an increased risk due to the vague wording of the legislation, specifically "reckless" sale of alcohol by the business. Also, you can be sure that if this legislation is passed, that rates will go up commensurately for not only Liquor Liability coverage, but if actual damages begin to be paid out under this law, that insurance rates on the whole will see an increase.
Read more

Get employees back to work quickly to keep work comp costs down

Image
In the past I have spoken to clients regarding a particular workers compensation claim affecting them and have asked if they have brought the employee back to work yet. Too many times the answer is no, they have nothing for that employee to do since said employee is not 100% and unable to perform their specific job prior to their workers compensation injury/claim. The problem with this is that too often employers miss the point that even though an employee can't perform in the position they were in prior to their injury, it behooves the employer to create some type of alternative task/job the employee can do until such time they are able to resume their normal duties. Bringing that employee back to work means that work comp benefits /payments in that particular claim are being curtailed, thereby saving the employer potentially more being paid out, while adding to their experience mod and driving their overall work comp expenses up.
Read more

Important to notify insurance company of potential liability claims

Image
When trying to manage their insurance policies, many business owners make the decision not to turn in potential claims and decide to take care of them on their own. By paying for small claims, such as property damage, etc, they strive to keep claim frequency down and in turn keep renewal premiums down. One area of insurance they should not try to manage though is potential liability situations/claims. Most policy conditions require prompt notification of any potential liability claims to the insurance company and if a claim isn't turned in promptly, the policy language does note that the company can deny a claim due to late notification. It's important to do this early on since information/memories are still fresh and it gives the insurance company time to completely investigate the potential claim. The potential for a liability claim is most likely the small business owner's greatest area of risk, whether they operate a restaurant, cleaning service or any other busi
Read more